Best Propane Smokers for 2019 – Indepth Reviews with Comparisons

If you’re looking for the best propane smoker check out our list below, which recommends smokers by category, and gives a ‘best overall’ choice, the Masterbuilt 20050614 Propane Smoker, 44-Inch, Black.

Masterbuilt 20050614 Propane Smoker, 44-Inch, Black

(Best Overall)

Masterbuilt GS40 20050211 Black Propane Smoker, 40-Inch, 40 Inch,
PROS:
  • Strong build quality with stainless steel dual doors. 
  • Embedded viewing window at the front.
  • Large cooking capacity.
CONS:
  • In-built thermometer  may not be completely accurate.
  • Smoke leaks from the door which can be an issue for some people.

Top 5 Best Propane Smokers Compared

Best Propane Gas Smoker
Best with Glass Door
Best if money is not an issue
Best Brandwise

Masterbuilt GS40 20050211 Black Propane Smoker, 40-Inch, 40 Inch,

Features

Masterbuilt is one of the most trusted game players in the smoker industry. Masterbuilt’s 44-Inch Propane Smoker with black powder coated outer shell and dual door technology, comes with front controller and viewing window. It is perfect for those who want to smoke great food and save time.

Capacity

This well-insulated propane smoker comes with 2,000 sq. inches. of cooking space.  With dimensions of  30.7 x 22.75 x 56.02  inches and four chrome-coated racks, the smoker can facilitate up to 35 pounds of meat.  The smoker weighs almost 40.5 kgs and allows you to smoke quality food in a great quantity.

Both the wood chip pan and the water pan are porcelain coated that can be placed in a separate compartment below the cooking chamber. This is especially a great feature since it allows easy access so that you can provide extra moisture and flavor to the meat without massive temperature drops. The smoker also comes with a stainless steel burner where the porcelain flame disk bowl can be placed.

Power and Temperature Controls

This smoker has a heating element in the form of a 15400 BTU stainless steel burner which helps the smoker to heat up quickly and evenly. The thermostat on the top of the door is easily readable  and allows you to set and maintain the required smoking temperature.

The viewing window makes the barbecuing experience much more enjoyable. Masterbuilt’s 44-inch propane smoker also features a gas control valve that is  powered by a Type 1 regulator and a hose. The easy to use smoker has two stainless steel burners powered by two simple push buttons, each of 8250 BTU.

Verdict

This propane smoker offers high-end features at a reasonable price and is great for people of all ages.

Dimensions

30.7 x 22.75 x 56.02  inches

Best for beginners.
Best Portable.
Best under $300.

Camp Chef Smoke Vault 24 inch

Features

If you are a beginner and wish to try your hands on a propane smoker that will be easy on your pocket, Camp Chef’s 24 inches Smoke Vault is a great choice. For less than $300, you get decent features and great quality food.  

 Capacity

The insulated, double-walled smoker is made of steel has dimensions 24″ W x 16″ D x 44″ H (with legs) and a cooking surface of 75 pounds. 

The smoker weighs around 34 kgs and can facilitate two adjustable chrome-plated smoking racks and one jerky smoking rack, 21 1/2″ x 14″ each. 

It has a decent-sized heavy gauge, removable, steel wood chip tray and water pans along with a  porcelain base tray that makes cleaning up quick and easy. 

Power and Temperature Controls

The most interesting feature is its 18,000 BTU/hr heating element that can reach up to 400° F. It also has three adjustable damper valves – one on top and one on each side to help keep meat moist, meanwhile also infusing flavor. 

With an easy to read thermometer on the door, this propane smoker resembles a bank vault and is backed with fully adjustable snap-ignition heat control dials that make smoking easier for beginners. The burner drum is protected to prevent heat loss and maintain internal temperatures.

 Verdict

This is the perfect low-end, affordable propane smoker that is excellent for beginners who want to test the waters.This smoker is compact and requires less space. The removable grease tray allows easy. mess-free cleanup and the steel legs provide stability thus vouching for its durability.

Dimensions

24″ W x 16″ D x 44″ H (with legs)

Best under $200.
Best propane smoker grill combo.

Char-Broil The Big Easy TRU-Infrared Smoker Roaster & Grill

Features

Char-Broil The Big Easy TRU-Infrared Smoker Roaster & Grill is a great quality propane smoker at an under $200 price point and excellent features. This is a perfect choice for those who want an all in one cooking solution at home!

Capacity

This 3-in-1 propane smoker, with dimensions: 23.1 x 23.4 x 36.2 inches weighs around 22.7 pounds.  This smoker is versatile and has 180 square inch cooking capacity with state of the art  Infrared Grilling Surface.

Furthermore, this one-stop solution comes with a 1200 square inch basket for smoking and roasting. It also comes with a removable grease tray, lift hook for the roasting basket,  two half racks and an instruction manual.

This small smoker can fit up to 25 pounds of meat for roasting. You can work with removable grill grates to prepare scrumptious barbecue. You can evenly cook all kinds of meat – turkey, chicken, roast along with vegetables without any flare-ups. Though difficult to clean, the grates have a unique design which ensures that food does not fall down.

Power and Temperature Controls

The stainless steel smoker, roaster and grill has a strong, durable build and two side-mounted carrying handles. The excellent temperature control options offers 9,000 to 18,000 BTU heating. Cooking in this beast is as simple as connecting a liquid propane tank and turning two knobs. The top-notch hose with regulator bring the smoker to life. 

The most interesting thing about this product is the fast cooking feature since it combines both convection cooking and Infrared cooking technology. The TRU infrared system produces crispy and oil-less fried food that is both juicy and tender. 

Both the wood chip pan and the water pan are placed in a separate compartment and easy access to them means you can add extra moisture and flavor to the meat without massive temperature drops.

However, the flame is not directly below the food which means that the drippings fall on the grease tray rather than vaporising.    

Verdict

Char-Broil The Big Easy TRU-Infrared Smoker Roaster & Grill  is convenient low price 3-in-1 solution for those who wish to try their hands on cooking with propane as a fuel.

Despite some flaws, it is a great choice for those who wish to have it all in a small package.

Dimensions

23.1 x 23.4 x 36.2 inches

Best under $500.
Best vertical propane smoker.

Landmann USA 3895GWLA Smoky Mountain Vertical Gas Smoker, 38-Inch, 26 inch Wide Chamber, Black

Features

Landmann USA 3895GWLA Smoky Mountain Vertical Gas Smoker is a high quality propane smokers that will be an asset in your business. It is the perfect choice for large cooking and commercial use.

Capacity

With dimensions: 26 x 21 x 47.25 inches, this slow cook smoker weighs 92.6 pounds. The   38-Inch propane smoker has a 26 inch wide cooking chamber and a cooking capacity of 1576-square inch. 

It comes with 5 adjustable chrome plated cooking grates and meat hanger which allow heavy duty slow cooking of around 50 pounds of meat in one shift. The heavy duty steel construction and welded cooking chamber gives this propane smoker an edge over its competitors.

Power and Temperature Controls

The square leg construction provides stability while the weather-resistant body keeps the internal workings of the smokers intact.

With a Cast iron burner for longer life, Adjustable Top Chimney vent, Fully adjustable side heat controls and drawers for easy access to the porcelain-coated, heavy duty water and wood chip pans this smoker has everything.

It also has adjustable heat controls, an adjustable chimney on the top of the smoker and temperature gauge on the from of the door.  The damper vents on the sides allow proper air ventilation for maximum temperature control. The rotary igniter helps in easy operation.

Verdict

The Landmann USA 3895GWLA Smoky Mountain Vertical Gas Smoker is a great for commercial use since it has a large smoking capacity and sturdy build which makes it portable!

Dimensions

26 x 21 x 47.25 inches

Best mid-range.
Best cheap propane smoker.
Best budget smoker.

Smoke Hollow 38202G 38-Inch 2-Door Propane Gas Smoker

Features

Smoke Hollow 38202G LPG 2-Door Smoker  is a mid-range propane smoker. The two-door design helps keep the temperature in check and allow you to smoke lots of food as it has plenty of space. The locking latch  on the door ensures that no heat escapes the cooking chamber.

Capacity

With dimensions: 19.73 x 27.32 x 47.1 inches,  Smoke Hollow’s LPG smoker weighs 68 pounds and has 3.4 cubic feet cubic capacity. The well-insulated wide area and strong build supports 4 adjustable chrome plated cooking grates and sausage hanger which make the cooking experience more enjoyable.

 It is made from heavy duty steel and has strong welded cooking chamber and exterior. This allows you to smoke a variety of foods at different temperatures.

Power and Temperature Controls

The 20000 BTU  propane heating element give unmatchable heating power allowing the smoker  to maintain an internal temperature of up to 350°F. The built-in temperature gauge is easy to read, however, the internal temperature may be off by 30 degrees.

It also has adjustable air vents that control the temperature to perfection. damper valves – one on top and one on the bottom to help keep meat moist, meanwhile also infusing flavor.  This smoker has drawers for easy access to the porcelain-coated, heavy duty water and wood chip pans.

The temperature range is, however, adjustable because the fuel used is propane. The burner is made of cast brass and can easily be operated using the push-button ignition system.

Verdict

Smoke Hollow 38202G LPG 2-Door Smoker is a decent propane smoker than balances both quality and quantity. It is a great option for those who wish to get the best smoker on a budget.

Dimensions

19.73 x 27.32 x 47.1 inches

What Factors Should You Consider When Buying a Propane Smoker?

The wide variety of propane smokers on the market makes choosing the perfect smoker a genuine concern. In truth, the one perfect smoker does not exist. However, here are some factors that you must consider before buying a propane smoker that is best suited for you.

Price – What is your budget?

Price has always been a major factor to consider when making a purchase and trumps other secondary factors. Propane smokers offer many great features for beginners at attractive price points whether low-end, mid-range or high-end.  

Are you a beginner looking for something affordable? Camp Chef 24 in Smoke Vault is the best beginner propane smoker to invest in. If you are one of those who wants to invest in  a one-stop shop solution, the 3-in-1 propane smoker, roaster and grill combo to look at is Char-Broil The Big Easy TRU-Infrared Smoker Roaster & Grill.

Temperature Control

Propane smokers, like electric ones, are quick and easy to use. The cooking process in these smokers does not require much prior experience and is generally less stressful as compared to other kinds of barbecue smokers.

Controlling the temperature in propane smokers is an essential aspect to consider. Efficient temperature controls offered in propane smokers today are further complemented by features such as smart cooking timers. 

Smoke Hollow 38202G LPG 2-Door Smoker  is a budget friendly propane smoker and comes with excellent temperature control while the Masterbuilt 20050614 Propane Smoker, 44-Inch, Black is suitable for those who are willing to invest in a high-end propane smoker with quality temperature controls.

Cooking Area, Size, Capacity and Portability

When investing in a propane smoker, it is essential that you know the purpose for your big purchase? This will help you decide the cooking area and size of the smoker. It could vary based on whether it is a more personal investment for home cooking or if you wish to buy the smoker for business.  

Smoke Hollow 38202G LPG 2-Door Smoker is the perfect pick if you wish to own a smoker with sufficient capacity on a budget.

A smoker for smaller house gatherings can be stationed and fixed while someone who needs to use it as  business equipment or carry it around will need to consider portability.

It is not wise or even practical to overload a small propane smoker with more meat since that will compromise the cooking experience. This is why  you need to consider the capacity before you buy a smoker. The size of the smoker is also of importance when in relation to the storage options available to you. If you desire portability and want to smoke on-the-go, Homia’s Starter Kit is the portable smoker for you.

Power

Before buying a new propane smoker, it is important that you look at the power of the heating element since it defines your smoker’s capability and strength.  On average, a smoker with 800 watts power has cooking area of around 800 square inches. Although the number of heat sources can shorten the cooking time, they can pose the risk of overcooking the food.

Food Tray Structure

Unlike many electric smokers, quite a few propane smokers come with the two-door technology which allows you to store the water and wood chip pans separately from the food trays. The design of these trays and their placement plays a vital role in one’s buying decision. Furthermore, the quality of these food trays are important factors to consider as the ones with higher quality to require less maintenance and the usage is hassle-free.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. How to use a Propane Smoker

 

Using a propane smoker doesn’t get easier!

Begin by buying a propane smoker. Once you have set up your smoker, prepare your food. You can cook almost anything in your propane smokers, from different kinds of meat to vegetables, fruits and even cheese.

In order to prepare your smoker, preheat the smoker for 15 minutes as it helps in disinfecting the insides. Meanwhile, for smoking, choose the wood chips of your choice and get them ready. You may do this by soaking the wood beforehand, if need be.

Once you smoker starts to heat up, you can manage the air flow to ensure even cooking of your food. While the food is in, do not open the smoker for at least 1.5 hours as it can affect the smoking process.
When your food is well done, you may enjoy it with your loved ones!

 

2. Precautions and Tips

 

Smoking food in a propane smoker, while enjoyable, comes with some safety hazards.

Avoid Gas Leakages
First of all, when you begin the smoking process, ensure that the hose that connects the cylinder to the smoker is tightly secured since gas leakages can wreak havoc.
Similarly, at the end of your cookout, it is essential that you turn off the burner and cylinder completely.

Preheat
Preheating one’s propane smoker before the initiation of a cookout is considered as good practise in the food industry. The 10 to 15 minutes long disinfection process creates a hygienic environment that is excellent for cooking.

Use the Right Kind of Wood
The right quality and kind of wood used can make all the difference. It is important to note that not all wood is meant for smoking.

Clean your Smoker When it is Cooled
Cleaning a hot smoker can put you at a risk of burns. Wait it out!

 

3. Can you safely run a Propane Smoker Overnight?

As long as your smoker is protected from the wind and is away from any flammable source, it is believed by many that one can safely operate a propane smoker. However, there is always some risk and it is always better to keep a frequent check on your smoker, ensuring that there isn’t any fire, leaking gas or flare-ups, rather than having to face a life-threatening hazard.

4. How to Smoke a Turkey in a Propane Smoker

Begin by preparing your turkey. You can keep the turkey rub simple, like salt, ground pepper, paprika, brown sugar and poultry seasoning. A simple rub is appreciated by guests of all ages.

Next, it is time to preheat your propane smoker to prep and disinfect. Begin by adding small wood chips which can later be replaced with bigger chunks when  you put the turkey in the smoker. An unstuffed turkey will take around 5 hours to cook completely. At a high cooking temperature it is better to use bigger wood because smaller wood chips burn too quickly. 

When your turkey is fully cooked, it will have a crispy crust. This is a good time to take the turkey out so as  to avoid over cooking.

5. Best Pellets for a Propane Smoker // Best Wood Chips for Propane Smoker

Wood chips add flavor to your food and hence it is important that you use the right kind of wood that will prevent flare-ups.

Some believe that soaking wood chips before smoking can add complexity to the food’s flavor if done with juices and doing so is a personal preference. However, this step is not necessary at all, since it can add extra moisture to the meat that you might not want.

Good quality wood chips and pellets last longer and are not chemically treated.

You can add different types of flavors to your food such as Alder, cherry, mulberry, nectarine, olive, peach and pecan.

Cookinpellets 40PM Perfect Mix Smoking Pellets is an excellent brand to begin with.

You can buy them online

6. Electric vs Propane Smoker

Propane smokers are easy to use, portable and great for camping. They require less cooking time as compared to electric smokers and unlike electric smokers, they have flexible dual door designs.

While electric smokers are very similar to propane smokers, they take much longer to cook food. The cooking time is at least twice as compared to a propane smoker cookout. Apart from the  difference in fuel usage, electric smokers are much safer than propane smokers as they can also be used indoors.

7. Propane Smoker vs Charcoal

Charcoal smokers are unmatchable when it comes to flavor authenticity but can be expensive. They can be much more difficult to work with and are suitable for experts. They tend to more messy and harmful to the environment as compared to propane smokers since they emit large amounts of carbon dioxide. In a study by scientists, the charcoal-grilled meats contain more carcinogens than the meat heated in propane smokers.

Check out propane smoker advantages above.

That’s all from this article if you want to explore more types of smoker like pellet smokers and offset smokers please feel free to browse through!